Team India have qualified for the semi-finals after a surprisingly unpredictable victory against Bangladesh. While this may be cause for cheer, the Indian cricket fan is known to be highly demanding of their team, and, if the fans are demanding, the commentators are sometimes even more so.
Sanjay Manjrekar, former cricketer and now-commentator, sparked criticism after a series of tweets criticizing Mahendra Singh Dhoni, Mohammed Shami and K.L. Rahul. Pointing out that Dhoni scored more runs off spin balls during the warm-up matches, he said the player and former India captain ‘does not put his wicket on the line as much during big games’.
Here’s something interesting about Dhoni -. 41 off 87 balls v spin this WC. But in the warm up games 69 off 56 balls v spin. That tells me it’s mental too. He does not put his wicket on the line as much in the big games.#ICCCWC2019
— Sanjay Manjrekar (@sanjaymanjrekar) July 2, 2019
This irked the fans. Some Twitter users responded calling it an unfair comparison for Dhoni, accusing Manjrekar's commentary of being biased..
Not really. MS has faced Mehidy Hasan and Mosaddek Hossain in the Warm up against Bangladesh. Those numbers are inflated.
— Ravi Maestri (@ravimaestri) July 2, 2019
And MS is normally too good against Offies, given the hitting range they offer
More trolling followed by popular Twitter handles, which hoped Manjrekar would stopped commenting on matches.
I'm praying #manjrekar has a toe niggle.
— Siddharth (@Actor_Siddharth) July 2, 2019
A Twitter account calling itself the ‘MS Dhoni’s official fan club’, with over three lakh followers, tweeted calling for Manjrekar’s removal.
Dear Starsports,
— MS Dhoni Fans Official (@msdfansofficial) July 2, 2019
A humble request from all the Indian Cricket Team fans, sack @sanjaymanjrekar. Please do not ruin the World Cup for us. #INDvBAN #Dhoni #TeamIndia pic.twitter.com/ViiBeRvkse
Manjerkar is not unused to angry comments. The day before his Dhoni tweet, he gave out a light-hearted take on the online trolling he receives on a regular basis, saying he sees ‘only love’ for him on Twitter.
Criticism, abuse? What are you saying Raunak? I see only love for me on Twitter. 😋 https://t.co/Ayb6BQtGCb
— Sanjay Manjrekar (@sanjaymanjrekar) June 30, 2019
ESPN commentator Raunak Kapoor had earlier come to Manjrekar’s defence.
On a side note, everyone has likes & dislikes in the comm box. And @sanjaymanjrekar is often at the receiving end of criticism & unwarranted abuse. But from the intent in the last 5 to tactical points through the game, he asked Virat Kohli ALL the right Questions post match. 👏🏻👏🏻
— Raunak Kapoor (@RaunakRK) June 30, 2019
Past controversies
The commentator has had controversial moments before. In 2017, when he was in the commentary box during IPL 10, he criticized the West Indies and then Mumbai Indians batsman Kieron Pollard after a match between Mumbai Indians and Royal Challengers Bangalore.
Fans misheard him as saying “Pollard has no brains” and erupted. Many media outlets reported that he had called the Windies batsman “brainless”, sparking fury online and offline.
Pollard himself responded with an emotional tweet.
Do you know how I get big so.. about BRAINLESS.. words are very powerful .. once it leaves u can't take it back.. sins of parents fall on...
— Kieron Pollard (@KieronPollard55) April 9, 2017
Manjrekar later clarified that he was saying that “Pollard has no range” and that fans had misheard him.
Said " Does he have the range? " Using terms like 'no brains' or 'brainless' not my style. I can be critical but never insulting.
— Sanjay Manjrekar (@sanjaymanjrekar) April 15, 2017
Pollard later deleted one of his tweets directed at Manjrekar.
He had another spat in 2015, after a Twitter exchange between him and Sania Mirza went viral. It started when Sania tweeted about retaining her place as the “number 1 player in d world” for 80 weeks.
While many congratulated her, Manjrekar did so but corrected her to add that she was the number 1 ‘doubles’ players.
No 1 doubles player you mean. Congrats! https://t.co/Qrdyigdrro
— Sanjay Manjrekar (@sanjaymanjrekar) October 19, 2016
Since Sania had not played singles matches since 2013, she replied saying it was a matter of common sense.
Well, you missed out an important detail for someone like me who lacks common sense :) https://t.co/nLgRFONxrn
— Sanjay Manjrekar (@sanjaymanjrekar) October 19, 2016
This sparked a brief but tense exchange between the two.